Hello dear
Welcome To Anthony's Italian Restaurant
Welcome to Anthony's Italian Restaurant, a beloved gem nestled in New Egypt, NJ. Known for its inviting family atmosphere and attentive service, Anthony's offers a delightful variety of Italian dishes and gourmet pizzas. Highlights include the Buffalo Fried Calamari and the cheesiest calzones that will leave you craving more. Guests rave about the generous pizza slices, especially the Meat Lover's and Eggplant Parmigiana varieties. With reasonable prices and a menu that satisfies every palate, Anthony's stands out as a go-to destination for both locals and visitors alike. This restaurant truly encapsulates the essence of comforting, home-style Italian cuisine.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Cheese Pizza
Tagiatelle Paglia E Fieno
Red Devil Wrap
Homemade Fettuccine Alfredo Sauce
Gnocchi Sorrentina
Penne Al Pesto
Linguine
Penne With Broccoli
Tortellini Bolognese
About
Anthony's Italian Restaurant
Welcome to Anthony's Italian Restaurant, your gateway to authentic Italian cuisine tucked away at 6 Jacobstown Rd, New Egypt, NJ. This family-owned eatery has been delighting patrons with its generous portions and warm hospitality for over three decades. With an inviting atmosphere and a menu bursting with flavor, it's no wonder Anthony's has become a cherished dining destination for locals and visitors alike.
If you’re a pizza aficionado, Anthony’s gourmet offerings will undoubtedly impress. Their Sicilian Special Pizza "The Works" serves up a delightful medley of toppings, while the classic Margherita Pizza showcases fresh ingredients, including sliced tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and aromatic basil. Don’t miss the Broccoli, Tomatoes & Ricotta Pizza for a refreshing twist, or indulge in the Chicken Parmigiana Pizza that melds savory chicken and cheesy goodness. For a creative adventure, the Penne al Pesto Pie is a must-try.
Beyond pizza, Anthony's menu features an array of delectable hot and cold appetizers. The Mussels Mediterranean in salsa marinara are a sumptuous start, while the Baked Clams Alla Anthony and Stuffed Mushrooms add a rich, hearty flavor to the unimposing ambiance. If you're in the mood for something adventurous, the Buffalo Fried Calamari delivers a spicy kick and crispy texture that seafood lovers will adore.
The glowing reviews speak volumes. Customers like Junior rave about the superb pizza and friendly staff, while Lorenzo praises the cheesiest calzone he's ever had. David insists that Anthony’s serves the best food in the area, all without stretching your wallet. Meanwhile, Curtis highlights the consistent quality of the hoagies and hearty burgers, praising the family-like care that the owners bring to every meal.
When dining at Anthony’s, you’re not just enjoying a meal; you’re partaking in a rich tradition of Italian hospitality. Whether you’re stopping by for a slice after visiting nearby attractions like Great Adventure, or sitting down for a cozy family dinner, you can expect delicious food and a welcoming atmosphere.
In a world filled with dining options, Anthony’s Italian Restaurant stands out as a quintessential gem that combines quality, value, and charm. The promise of great food and memorable experiences keeps diners coming back for more. So next time you're in the area, make sure to taste the magic of Anthony's—your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This place is super good, the size of the slices are amazing and the the price is decent for a slice I would come again ”
“ Anthony's has the best and cheesiest calzone I had ever had. The staff are very polite, and the restaurant has a welcoming family owned atmosphere. I came here while visiting Great Adventure, which is not too far away. I recommend eating here. ”
“ Very good food, excellent Pizza, staff are super friendly... ”
“ This place has the best food in the area! Been working in the area for awhile now and it's absolutely fantastic food! Eat here if you ever get the chance. Plus it's very reasonable on your pockets! ”
“ I have been a patron of Anthony's for 3 decades. Never had a bad meal. Great hoagies, cheesesteaks, hearty burgers, and Italian dishes. The staff has always been very nice. Owners always thank you for the business. Encourage everyone to give them a try. Enjoy! ”
“ Very friendly service from the time we walked in till we left. The food was hot and delicious. There was hardly any wait time to get our food, and they brought it to the table. We are visiting NJ and had to have a white pie. ”
“ Coming back from the Winery, we needed to stop to eat something before the ride home. We came across Anthony's and figured we would stop for a slice. Sure enough we sat down and had a feast. Plate after plate of food our host kept bringing us courses nonstop. The owners were one of the nicest couple I have ever met. They made the food taste unbelievable. I felt like I was in someone's home. Take the food what it is and just enjoy the good company. Make sure you try their pasta salad. They make it with homemade pesto. I defiantly recommend this place with no hesitations. ”
“ First time ordering. Will definitely be back!!!! So delicious!!! Ordered the Chicken Florentina with Linguine and Chicken Parmigiana with Ziti. Chicken Florentina was wonderful. The wine sauce gave great flavor. Pasta....perfect bite! Chicken filled with Prosciutto, spinach, mozzarella...you can never go wrong. Flavors were amazing!!! Hubby had the Chicken Parmigiana and the sauce was perfect!!! Chicken was tender!! Delicious!!! Food came with bread. Crusty outside and soft inside!! Great portion sizes!! ”